Once a year we pay homage to the Super Bowl. It’s kinda like Thanksgiving, you get really excited by the prospect of the big event, but seldom does the day truly live up to the hype.
Given that advertising research is a passion of mine I feel it appropriate to share my point of view on the championship showdown.
The Ads
And the winner goes to Bubly water. Think about it... of all the ads you saw, what brand name did you actually remember? The #bublyvsbublé play on words; Bubly water vs Michael Bublé was genius. And Michael with his sharpe pen at the end, righting the (perceived) wrong of his misspelled last name was simply entertaining. Kudos to the ad agency and marketing team.
One of the worst ads for me was Oil of Olay. Wow! What was the scary movie idea all about? I found it completely off-brand, and too much of an abstract idea for a brand that is rooted in the credible promise of skin rejuvenation.
Budweiser. ‘Disappointing’ would be the one word take away. Why? They get one shot every year and it seems like they aim to talk about anything but themselves. I was really hoping they would take center stage and make the narrative all about them. Instead they focused on saving energy. Yes this is a subject matter this is extremely important and we commend all companies that chose to take a positive stance in this area but is advertising at the Super Bowl the right forum? I don’t think so.
Let’s keep it real. The money spent on a single GRP during the Super Bowl is high, creative quality should be exceptional to truly cease the opportunity.
My prediction. Sales for Bubly water are going to rocket, while Budweiser sales will not to be positively influenced by the overpriced ticket they paid to advertise during this prime time event.
The Game
A defensive game is never as rewarding as offence and open play. That being said I am sure there are a core group of people who appreciate the strategic plays that had the score sitting at 3-3 in the third. Inversely I’m sure many were bored and underwhelmed.
The Halftime Show
Queen B and Prince continue to reign. I wasn’t enamored by any of the talent that took centre stage despite some of the songs being classics. Yes, the expectations are high. The audience is captivated. The stage has been set. Yet the performance just didn’t deliver. Sigh. If only we could bring back Purple Rain, in the rain and the marching and drum bands. We want and expect more!!!!
My critique is based on years of experience in reviewing thousands of ads for hundreds of brands. If you would like to learn more about how the Foresight Strategy Group can help avoid advertising nightmares and ensure your ad shines and drives sales, feel free to reach out to us for a confidential consultation. Contact: sabrina@foresightstrategygroup.com.
When Roger Federer is on the court, time stops, and millions watch the living legend do what he does best – play exceptional tennis. During that time all we see is what is happening on the court at that specific moment. What we don’t see is the endless hours of preparation that have led to that winning moment. To be the best, one has to work hard, and timing is everything.
Yet in the world of advertising and communications, timing seems finite. There never seems to be enough time but we expect to create an exceptional execution that is worthy of an award. At On Point Insight we seek to partner with our marketing clients and advertising partners to create brand building advertising that is worthy of consumer attention - but we ask you for one thing; a little more time.
We believe that every brand has the ability to generate impactful advertising in any medium. We are not sold on the speculation of low involvement categories. If done right, every brand has a voice that can lure the consumer, it just requires the right tone and content. However, as with our tennis analogy, preparation is essential to success.
A true insight
Every strong execution requires an ad strategy, a big idea, and a way of talking about the brand that…
is attached to a relevant consumer insight
is attached to a functional and/or emotional benefit
provides a clear reason to believe
is wrapped with a succinct positioning line